Dedicated to the balanced discussion of global warming
Several days ago, I posted about RealClimate.org’s defense of the 9 ‘mistakes’ that a British court found in “An Inconvenient Truth” (AIT). My review was not well regarded by many at RealClimate as they defended their defense. My point at the time was that extremism is bad in all ways. Even if you think that the world is going to end due to human induced global warming, you must be able to see spin for what it is and confront it.
Conversely, if you think that all this global warming conversation is hooey, you still should not say that everything out of Mr. Gore’s mouth is biased and wrong. We need to evaluate each claim on its own and seriously discuss the viable issues.
Now I would like to do a review of the Science and Public Policy Institute (SPPI) to see if they were more fair in their analysis. I will let you, my readers, be the judge. You can read their analysis here.
My review of the SPPI claims comes from my own watching of the movie as well as the unofficial transcripts of the movie.
Due to the number of errors that SPPI is claiming, I cannot do this justice in one posting. So I am spreading this out over the next 5 days with the final day being my impression on the entire effort from Mr. Gore as well as the work of SPPI. I am going to not allow comments on the individual posts until after the fifth posting and then you are welcome to point out my mistakes as you wish. All 5 posts are already written, I have just learned that long articles tend to get skipped over so I broke up the finished product.
ERROR 1 – SPPI has this correct from what I understand. This is similar to the error that the UK judge found.
ERROR 2 – I don’t know about the claim that corals grow at ten times the the rate of increase in sea level. Not sure that is relevant in this discussion. However, SPPI is correct that there have been no mass evacuations as Mr. Gore claimed.
ERROR 3 – SPPI has this correct, I believe. Once again, this is the same as what the judge found.
ERROR 4 – I don’t believe that Mr. Gore ever said the words “in each of the last four interglacial warm periods it was changes in carbon dioxide concentration that caused changes in temperature.” This is a bit of spin by SPPI. There is no question that Mr. Gore tried to make people think that CO2 caused the rise in temperature. Once again, this is simply a repeat of the judge.
ERROR 5 – It is pretty well accepted that the primary influence on the snows of Kilimanjaro is humidity levels and the drop in those is likely the activity of man in that area but it is not global warming.
ERROR 6 – SPPI is correct on Lake Chad.
ERROR 7 – I believe that SPPI has this correct as well. While Ms. Kreider is correct that Mr. Gore never specifically said that Katrina was the result of global warming, he definitely made his viewers feel that it was.
I do need to point out here that SPPI threw in a bit of spin on this one. They blamed the Clinton/Gore administration for not adequately building the levees that failed. While this was true, the same argument could be made for the Reagan/Bush, Bush/Quayle, and Bush/Cheney administrations. For that matter, since the current levees were in response to Hurricane Betsy of 1965 we could blame every administration since then for only paying for Category 3 hurricanes.
SPPI is correct that according to NOAA, there has been no abnormal increase in the number of hurricanes however that doesn’t prove much since the sample set is so small – we haven’t been counting ocean based hurricanes for very long.
ERROR 8 – The SPPI is correct that we cannot discern any change in polar bear population due to global warming. To be fair, this is a bad metric and AIT should never have used it. The polar bear population has increased so substantially over the past few decades that it would be impossible to say that climate change was good or bad for these animals. Once again, this is a case for a true discussion of causality and since the current change in population is due to human meddling, we need to stop using the plight of the polar bears.
ERROR 9 – It appears that SPPI is correct on this issue.
Did you know that you can have these articles emailed to you? Click on the here.Did you know that you can have these articles emailed to you? Click on the Subscribe to email link in the upper right corner, fill out the details, and you are set. No one will see your email address and you won’t get more spam by doing this.
Al Gore, An Inconvenient Truth, animals, carbon dioxide, causality, CO2, coral, corn, hurricanes, Kilimanjaro, NOAA, ocean, polar, Polar bear, RealClimate, Reid, science, snow, temperature
COMMENTS ARE CURRENTLY TURNED OFF. Comments are now on.